Creamarie Ice Cream, My Family's Reaction!

Discover what happened when my family tried Creamarie Ice Cream for the first time. From flavors to texture, here’s our honest review of this artisanal treat.

When it comes to ice cream, my family has tried just about every brand and flavor out there. So when we got the chance to taste Creamarie Ice Cream for the first time, we were excited to see if it lived up to the hype. Known for its artisan-quality ingredients and unique flavors, Creamarie promises a rich, creamy texture and bold taste. But does it really stand out? Here’s our full review.

First Impressions: Packaging and Presentation

The moment we opened the package, we could tell that Creamarie takes presentation seriously. The design was sleek and modern, with clear labeling that showcased each flavor. The ice cream arrived well-packed, still frozen, and ready to serve. Unlike mass-produced brands, Creamarie’s packaging had an artisanal touch, making it feel like a premium treat before we even took the first bite.

The Taste Test: Our Honest Thoughts

To get a well-rounded opinion, we decided to try a variety of flavors. Here’s what we thought of each one:

1. Classic Vanilla Bean

Vanilla might seem simple, but a good vanilla ice cream sets the standard for quality. Creamarie’s version was anything but ordinary. It had a deep, rich vanilla flavor with a smooth and creamy texture. Unlike some brands that taste artificial, this one had an authentic, homemade feel.

2. Chocolate Fudge Swirl

This one was a crowd favorite. The combination of rich chocolate ice cream with ribbons of decadent fudge created the perfect balance of sweetness and intensity. The chocolate flavor was bold without being overwhelming, and the fudge swirl added just the right amount of indulgence.

3. Salted Caramel Crunch

This flavor surprised us the most. The creamy caramel base was perfectly balanced with a hint of sea salt, and the crunchy mix-ins gave it a satisfying texture. If you love the combination of sweet and salty, this is a must-try.

4. Strawberry Shortcake

One of the more refreshing options, this flavor featured real strawberry pieces and chunks of buttery shortcake mixed into a velvety ice cream base. It tasted like a homemade dessert, making it one of the most unique flavors we’ve had.

Texture and Quality

Creamarie Ice Cream lived up to its reputation when it came to texture. Every scoop was incredibly smooth, rich, and creamy, without the icy or overly airy consistency found in some store-bought brands. The premium ingredients were evident, making each bite feel indulgent and satisfying.

Would We Buy It Again?

The verdict was unanimous—yes. Creamarie Ice Cream exceeded our expectations with its bold flavors, high-quality ingredients, and luxurious texture. While it may be a bit more premium in price, the quality justifies the cost, making it a great choice for special occasions or a well-deserved treat.

If you’re looking for an ice cream brand that delivers on taste and texture, Creamarie is definitely worth trying. Whether you love classic flavors or unique twists, there’s something for everyone in their lineup. After our first experience, we can’t wait to try more!

I'm eating honey peach Rocky Road. Rocky Road smalls, peach. Oh chip dough. This is smores the main one that I know that I tried was peach and honey because that was just my favorite was absolutely delicious. I like Rocky Road, the marshmallows in it or whatever they are. They're really good. I like kind of like the creamy I guess you could kind of say like loose chocolate. I liked that about it. I mean this looks good. So this is our chip dough and it uses oat flour instead of regular flour. So it's gluten free friendly. What I like about rocky road is that has like a mix has nuts, which is like a fun flavor. And then I'm pretty sure it has like marshmallows in it and also time, which are always really good. I think I like the like marshmallow II goopy goo. Just marshmallow. It's delicious. It makes it feel like a real smore you can taste like the graham cracker part of it. You can taste the Hershey's chocolate. I don't know that it tastes exactly like Hershey's chocolate but it's that chocolaty like graham cracker flavor. And then you can taste all that like marshmallow goo. It's really good. It was very creamy. Like there's a lot of peach in it, which is awesome. Mm hmm. That is very creamy. Peachy. Yeah, I can taste the honey. You can taste a creamy flavor with it. It's everything in the milk when you drink the milk after your peaches and cream. It's thick. And it doesn't just like dissolve really fast. Really, really flavorful. It's so good. Do you taste the peach? Yeah. Do you taste the cream? Do you taste Honey? Yeah. Does that all taste good together? Yeah. It has like those little pieces and the ice cream. And the white so crunchy. There's something white in the ice cream. And it looks kind of like something like s'mores like marshmallow. Yeah. And it is. It also has chocolate in it. Because my favorite ice cream ish chocolate, the chocolate, chocolate. I like that it's mixed and very, very creamy. I like the oat texture. I like this because it's creamy, that's fun to chew. I would prefer having Creamery over a lot of the standard things that I buy at the store, mostly because they are extremely sweet. Ice cream doesn't need to just be super sweet to be enjoyed. It's creamy. I can taste some marshmallow with it. It has like small chocolate tastes and I like that I can taste a little graham cracker. I think it's very smooth. The marshmallow just kind of blends in with the ice cream. I'd say this is my new favorite flavor of ice cream. This is like the best in the world. Automatic roller coaster in your mouth. It's more of like a gentle ride for sure like good. It's like the perfect amount of crunchy truly chocolatey. Like the marshmallow kind of gives it a little bit of like a build off of the ice cream adds more to it. Like honestly probably like the best rocky road I've had for a hot minute. Hopefully I get a VIP shipment of this every month. A lot of like the ice creams you get at like Walmart or whatever. They're kind of like cheap, but this feels like high quality and like really rich and good good. I do like the knots in there. It's really good. They're very stretchy, which is honestly really fun to eat. You can tell to marshmallow and not like this. Who knows what possibly marshmallow I wouldn't mind check them for a while yeah, do you like to eat ice cream a lot? Yeah, yeah. What do you like so much about ice cream? blushes to ice cream you happy? Yeah. Chocolate smartphones something else that's like kind of hard. But I don't know it is. Yeah, probably. No. No. Most thing I like about it is the whole thing. Exciting. Wow. It's really creamy. I like the chocolate for sure. Actually, I prefer the odd kind of flavor. It's almost a little nappy. It's really good. Yeah, the chocolates really good. I mean, it is sweet, but they're almost a little salty with the oat flour. Pretty good. I like that. It's not so sweet. I'm not a huge fan of overly sugary treats. So this is a big win for me. I think I like that you can just go out to get ice cream. I love like the trip that's involved with ice cream like it's a date night it's like movie food like it's all of it. You can do it for like an excursion or you can just bring it home and everyone just chow down like it's the perfect snack for the family and it's like something that's good for like everyone to just gather it's easy you just scoop it into a bowl and like everyone's happy that guy would eat this for breakfast and sort of my it's just been cream you know, it's not something I'll get sick of either. Yeah, you know like if it's something is too chocolatey or too much. I can't eat it all but I could eat a lot of this so it's really good. Well, you just look at the camera and smile for a second.

Subscribe to get notified about new videos!

Thank you! Your submission has been received!

Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Are you ready to make delicious, artisan ice cream from home?

Take your love for ice cream to the next level! Whether you’re a beginner or a seasoned maker, our artisan ice cream-making books, shop, workshops and resources will help you craft creamy, delicious flavors right from your kitchen. From classic favorites to unique creations, we’ll guide you through every step.