If you're traveling through Custer, South Dakota, and craving a slice of homemade pie, the Purple Pie Place is a spot you won’t want to miss. Known for its bright purple exterior, welcoming atmosphere, and delicious handmade pies, this local favorite has become a go-to destination for both tourists and locals.

During our visit, we tried a few of their famous pies, soaked in the small-town charm, and explored what makes this place stand out. Here’s our full review.

First Impressions

Driving up to the Purple Pie Place, you can’t miss it. The building is painted in a bold shade of purple, giving it a fun and inviting feel. The outdoor seating area adds to the charm, making it a great place to relax and enjoy dessert on a sunny day. Inside, the space is cozy, with a nostalgic diner-style vibe that feels warm and welcoming.

The Pie Selection

Purple Pie Place is known for its wide variety of pies, all made fresh daily. Some of their most popular flavors include:

• Bumbleberry Pie – A unique mix of blueberries, blackberries, and raspberries, creating a perfect balance of sweet and tart.
• Raspberry-Rhubarb Pie – A classic combination that blends the sweetness of raspberries with the slight tang of rhubarb.
• Peach Pie – A simple yet flavorful option made with fresh peaches and a flaky crust.
• Chocolate Cream Pie – A rich and creamy choice for chocolate lovers.

Taste Test: What We Tried

Bumbleberry Pie

This was the standout flavor. The mix of berries created a deep, vibrant taste that wasn’t overly sweet. The crust was golden, flaky, and perfectly baked, providing a great contrast to the juicy filling.

Raspberry-Rhubarb Pie

If you enjoy a little tartness in your dessert, this pie is a winner. The raspberries add sweetness, while the rhubarb brings a slight tang, making it a well-balanced treat.

Chocolate Cream Pie

Smooth, rich, and decadent, the Chocolate Cream Pie was the perfect option for those looking for something beyond fruit-based pies. The chocolate filling was silky, with just the right level of sweetness.

Beyond Pie – Other Menu Options

While pie is the main attraction, the Purple Pie Place also serves lunch options like sandwiches, quiches, and homemade ice cream. Their huckleberry ice cream is a local favorite, offering a refreshing and creamy addition to the dessert menu.

Overall Experience

• Atmosphere: Fun, welcoming, and filled with small-town charm.
• Service: Friendly staff who are happy to recommend flavors and share the history of the place.
• Food Quality: Fresh, homemade, and packed with flavor.

Is It Worth a Visit?

Absolutely. If you find yourself in Custer, South Dakota, the Purple Pie Place is a must-visit. The homemade pies, charming atmosphere, and friendly service make it a standout spot for anyone looking to experience a taste of the Black Hills. Whether you're stopping by for a quick slice or enjoying a full meal, this place delivers on both quality and experience.

Would we go back? Without a doubt. If you love classic, homemade pies and a fun, quirky atmosphere, this place is well worth the trip.