Cookie dough ice cream is a fan favorite, and for good reason. The combination of creamy vanilla ice cream with chunks of sweet, doughy goodness is hard to beat. To put it to the test, I compared two popular flavors from Ben & Jerry’s with my own Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream from Creamarie Co. The goal was to see how the flavors, textures, and overall experience stacked up.

The Contenders

1. Ben & Jerry’s Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

A classic in the ice cream world, this flavor features vanilla ice cream packed with chunks of chocolate chip cookie dough. Known for its rich and creamy base with soft, sweet dough pieces, it’s a go-to for cookie dough lovers.

2. Ben & Jerry’s Non-Dairy Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

This version offers a plant-based alternative, made with a vanilla-flavored non-dairy frozen dessert, gobs of chocolate chip cookie dough, and fudge flakes. It’s designed for those who avoid dairy but still want that indulgent cookie dough experience.

3. Creamarie Co.’s Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough (Oat Chip Dough) Ice Cream

A unique take on cookie dough ice cream, this flavor blends a creamy vanilla base with oatmeal chocolate chip cookie dough. The addition of oats gives it a slight chewiness, while the balance of chocolate and salt enhances the flavor.

Taste Test Results

Flavor Comparison

• Ben & Jerry’s Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough – This flavor delivered a strong vanilla base with plenty of sweet, chewy cookie dough pieces. The chocolate chips added richness, but overall, the flavor leaned heavily on the sweetness.
• Ben & Jerry’s Non-Dairy Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough – The non-dairy base had a slightly different texture, with a more noticeable aftertaste from the alternative milk used. The cookie dough pieces were still satisfying, but the flavor didn’t feel as balanced as the original.
• Creamarie Co.’s Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough – The oat-based dough provided a slightly nutty, complex flavor that paired well with the creamy vanilla base. The saltiness from the oatmeal and the dark chocolate chips made this version stand out with a deeper, more layered taste.

Texture Comparison

• Ben & Jerry’s Classic – Soft cookie dough pieces, smooth vanilla ice cream.
• Ben & Jerry’s Non-Dairy – Slightly icier texture, but good mix-ins.
• Creamarie Co. Oat Chip Dough – Creamier texture with a slight chew from the oats, giving it a more homemade feel.

Which One Wins?

While Ben & Jerry’s classic version is a nostalgic favorite, Creamarie Co.’s Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream stood out for its balance of sweet and salty, as well as its unique texture. The addition of oats added a subtle chewiness that made it feel more like freshly baked cookie dough.

For those who prefer a traditional experience, Ben & Jerry’s original is still a solid choice. However, if you’re looking for a cookie dough ice cream with a more complex flavor profile, Creamarie Co.’s version is worth a try.

Final Thoughts

Cookie dough ice cream is all about the mix-ins, and each of these flavors brought something different to the table. Whether you love the classic taste, need a non-dairy option, or want something with a little more depth, there’s a cookie dough ice cream for everyone. If you’re a fan of sweet and salty combinations, Creamarie Co.’s Oat Chip Dough is a must-try.