Peppermint Bark Ice Cream Review

Blue Bell Ice Cream is known for its classic flavors, but how does their Peppermint Bark stack up? Here’s my honest review on taste, texture, and overall experience.

Blue Bell Ice Cream has long been a favorite brand for its rich flavors and creamy texture. With the holiday season in full swing, I couldn’t resist trying their Peppermint Bark ice cream. This limited-edition flavor promises the perfect balance of cool peppermint, rich chocolate, and creamy ice cream. But does it live up to the hype? Here’s my full review.

First Impressions: Packaging and Presentation

Blue Bell keeps its packaging classic and recognizable, and the Peppermint Bark flavor is no exception. The label immediately sets the holiday tone, making it an inviting choice for the season. Upon opening the carton, I noticed generous chunks of peppermint bark swirled into the creamy base, hinting at a rich and flavorful experience.

Taste Test: How Does It Compare?

1. Peppermint Flavor

The peppermint is strong but not overpowering. It delivers a cool and refreshing taste that balances well with the sweetness of the ice cream. Unlike some peppermint flavors that feel artificial, this one tastes natural and smooth.

2. Chocolate Swirls and Bark Pieces

One of the best parts of this flavor is the peppermint bark itself. The chocolate pieces are rich and slightly crunchy, adding a nice contrast to the creamy ice cream. The chocolate-to-peppermint ratio is well-balanced, ensuring neither flavor overpowers the other.

3. Ice Cream Base

The base is classic Blue Bell—smooth, rich, and creamy. It holds up well against the mix-ins, allowing all the flavors to shine without feeling too heavy. The texture is exactly what you’d expect from a premium ice cream, making each bite satisfying.

Texture and Quality

Blue Bell consistently delivers a high-quality ice cream experience, and the Peppermint Bark flavor is no exception. The creamy texture, combined with the crunch of the peppermint bark pieces, creates a balanced contrast that keeps every spoonful interesting. The mix-ins are well-distributed, so you’re never left with a plain bite.

Is It Worth Trying?

If you’re a fan of holiday flavors, Blue Bell’s Peppermint Bark ice cream is a must-try. It’s festive, flavorful, and well-balanced, making it a perfect seasonal treat. The combination of cool peppermint, rich chocolate, and creamy ice cream delivers exactly what you’d expect from a holiday-inspired dessert.

Would I buy it again? Absolutely. It’s a great option for peppermint lovers and anyone looking for a festive ice cream to enjoy during the colder months. If you see it in stores, grab a carton before it disappears for the season.

hey there today I am taste testing bluebells ice cream, peppermint bark, and I've never had this flavor before, but I am a fan of their plain peppermint ice cream. And I was only introduced to it last year actually, and I love it. But I've never had this one. So I'm excited to see how it tastes. Oh, there's white ice cream. Probably has peppermint extract, chocolate chips, and maybe some candy cane. I don't know. Or maybe it's wonderful. It's chocolate yummy. I love how peppermint tea it is. I think those are candy canes. Oh, no. Maybe it is white chocolate. Yeah. Yeah. It's white chocolate bark. That's why it's bark with candy cane in it. And then little chocolate chip pieces. Very fun. I don't like the chocolate chip pieces. I like the flavor of it. But biting into the chocolate chip. I don't love and there's a little aftertaste to me. A lot of people say that chocolate has accident. Chocolate does not have wax in it. Not good chocolate anyway, but the aftertaste of this chocolate chip tastes like it has some wax to it. whether it does or not, I don't know. But that could just be because it's frozen. And I don't like frozen chocolate chip pieces. I do like the peppermint bark. Now the quality of the ice cream. Here's the thing that I have learned. The higher your butterfat is, then it doesn't melt as quickly. When it hits my tongue starts to melt pretty quickly. Also the churning time of ice cream and a lot of manufactured ice creams, they're just overrun with air is so you're getting a whole bunch of air in your pint versus actual ice cream product. So you get a lighter ice cream and not a denser ice cream. And I prefer a dense ice cream. I think that it tastes better in my mouth. And the texture, the whole sensation is just better. But the flavor of this ice cream is really good. I just don't love how much air is in there. When I'm squeezing this. I can squeeze the container. And that means that it's too soft, it has too much air in it. If you're going strictly on flavor, this is great. But if you're going for density of ice cream, no, it's melting pretty quickly. Meaning that it's got air in there and the fat content is not very high. Most of the flavor. I've actually not tried many of their flavors, but I do really like Bluebell. They have good flavors, the one that's i the ones that I've tried. But when you're buying ice cream, most ice creams you will buy in the grocery store will have a lot of overrun meaning it's overturned. There's a lot of air. So you get these billowy fluffy ice creams versus a really nice dense product. When you have dense ice cream you have more product and you can actually feel the weight difference in the two where this one if you held it up against a dense ice cream, it would be like this one is heavy one is light. I mean even looking at that you can really see and it hasn't been out for very long, but it is already really squishy. really soft. And maybe that doesn't matter to you. Maybe you just want ice cream to eat ice cream or baby the flavor is what you're going for versus that melted immediately in my mouth versus the quality of the texture of your mouth. I do like this ice cream because I like the flavor. And I have not yet made a peppermint ice cream but that is coming and I'm excited to make it. So there you go. Blue Bell Ice Cream, peppermint bark, good flavor. I like it a lot. For more ice cream reviews. Please subscribe

Subscribe to get notified about new videos!

Thank you! Your submission has been received!

Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Are you ready to make delicious, artisan ice cream from home?

Take your love for ice cream to the next level! Whether you’re a beginner or a seasoned maker, our artisan ice cream-making books, shop, workshops and resources will help you craft creamy, delicious flavors right from your kitchen. From classic favorites to unique creations, we’ll guide you through every step.